Showing posts with label Full Council Meeting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Full Council Meeting. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 08, 2014

Diary Date - Full Council - Tuesday 8 April

Full Council
Tuesday 8 April - 2pm
Council Chamber
And you can now watch online here.

The last full council meeting before the elections on the 22 May. Key items on the agenda:

  • Question Time - including questions from the public
  • Annual Report of the Council Business Management Committee
  • Scrutiny Reports
    • Tackling Childhood Obesity
    • Working with Housing Associations
  • Motions from members
    • Labour motion proposing support for the City Centred Campaign 
    • Tory motion proposing annual report from each Cabinet member to Full Council

Friday, April 04, 2014

Speech to budget meeting

 Belatedly, here's the original text of the speech I gave to the Budget Meeting in March (unchecked against delivery because I'm not going to watch myself - it is nerve-wracking enough delivering this). We had already had the annual invasion by the Birmingham Against the Cuts protestors, including one gentleman whose spectacular run down one of the aisles would have been more impressive if he hadn't run down one that was blocked at the end.

I started with a quote from Cllr Tilsley, Lib Dem, dating from February 2011, when he wrote to the Times, along with other Lib Dem councillors:

"These cuts will have an undoubted impact on all frontline council services... Rather than assist the country's recovery by making savings to the public in a way that can protect local economies and the front line, the cuts are structured in a way they will do the opposite."

That was then. Now things are worse.

We have a govt that talks a good game. They talk of freedom and localism, but it is a localism constrained by limits from the centre.

We have a govt that stays silent as half a million people rely on food banks, but Eric Pickles will leap into action to defend people who wish to park on double yellow lines.

We have a government that encourages the rich with tax cuts, but beats the poor with benefit sanctions.

We have a government that ignores rocketing child poverty, but when the floodwater laps at the playing fields of Eton, it opens the chequebook. 

This is a government that has social injustice and insecurity as a policy direction, as a desired outcome.

As Cllr Brigid Jones pointed out - even here, we have opposition councillors leaping to defend green waste collections, but silent on child services, social care and tackling poverty. Indeed, their proposals would further impoverish our lowest paid workers.

We have a new councillor joining us, who ran on a platform of standing up for Kingstanding and I'll welcome Cllr Sambrook to the chamber. Please, no more songs.   Sadly, the rest of his party has been lying down for the past few years and today shows them as supine in the face of government as ever.

To detail and the fantasy budgets from the opposition, only slightly more realistic than that proposed by our earlier visitors.

Cllr Tilsley suggested that we should cut the mythical bins police and instead try to track dumped fridges by their serial numbers. I have to tell him that in my decade of experience with a major UK white goods retailer, that those serial numbers are not recorded at point of sale and are certainly not retained in the second hand market.

Cllr Tilsley wants to restore the cuts in street cleaning. Sadly, he doesn't want to restore the 23% cut he and his colleagues voted through in 2012 that has been disfiguring my ward for two years. I will also remind him that the living wage remains his party's national policy, although it has been opposed by his party in Birmingham, controlled as they are by John Hemming.

I note that they promise to achieve £7m of savings in directorates. Their record in Yardley of working within budgets suggests that this pie in the sky at local level.

Cllr Alden promises me a new micro park for Acocks Green. This would be welcome, but I would like to know what he proposes to demolish to accommodate it. We already have to fight against his government's planning regime to hold onto our limited green space.

I was amazed to hear that he wants to outsource more administration. I have two words for him. 

Service. 

Birmingham.

if the people of Birmingham had been less wise in 2010, young Bobby would have been sat on very different and better upholstered benches, cheering on the coalition as they wielded the axe. Instead he tries to shift the blame to Labour. The Lib Dems do the same, ignoring the facts that under a Labour govt, they had the benefit of year on year above inflation increases in grant and the power to borrow, rather different from the policy that their government enforces on Birmingham.

Cllr Brew raised the deficits run by Labour. He fails to mention that the national debt was lower before the crash than when his party left office in 1997. And I do not believe that this crash was caused by spending on litter picking. Cllr Hutchings fails to mention that in opposition, David Cameron promised to match Labour spending. Their govt has borrowed more in four years than we did in thirteen.

Cllr Hunt spoke of public squalor, as if this Labour council would choose to scrap green waste collections or cut back on street cleaning as if it were not one of the least worst options to protect other, even more critical services.

It is with a heavy heart that I urge this council to support the Labour budget, unamended.

Sir Albert has been criticised as a doom monger, a Cassandra.

Remember this.

Cassandra was right. 

Monday, December 02, 2013

Diary Date - Full Council

Full Council
Tuesday 3 December 2013 - 2pm
Council Chamber, Council House
And you can now watch online here.

Key items on the agenda:
  • Question Time
    • Members of the Public to any Cabinet Member or District Committee Chair
    • Any Councillor to Committee Chair or Lead Member
    • Councillors other than Cabinet Members to Cabinet Member
    • Councillors other than Cabinet Members to Leader or Deputy Leader
  • Report of Council Business Management Committee
    • Proposed Changes to the Constitution
      • Changes to the senior management and departmental structure
  • Report of the Executive
    • Birmingham Development Plan
    • New governance arrangements for integrated transport authority
  • Report of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee
    • Children and Families with no recourse to public funds
  • Motions for Debate
Incidentally - I missed last month's meeting for unavoidable family reasons. 

Tuesday, October 08, 2013

Diary Date - Full Council Meeting

Full Council
Tuesday 8 October 2013 - 2pm
Council Chamber, Council House
And you can now watch online here.

Key items on the agenda:
  • Question Time
    • Members of the Public to any Cabinet Member or District Committee Chair
    • Any Councillor to Committee Chair or Lead Member
    • Councillors other than Cabinet Members to Cabinet Member
    • Councillors other than Cabinet Members to Leader or Deputy Leader
  • Report of Executive
    • Leader of the Council
    • Amendments of Terms of Reference for WM Joint Committee
    • Creation of Joint Scrutiny Committee for Supervisory Board for the Greater Birmingham and Solihull Local Enterprise Partnership
  • Proposed Changes to the Constitution
    • Extending full council meetings to 7pm
    • Time for motions to the council to be extended to 90m from 60m
    • Members of the public seeking to ask questions should attend in person to ask or the question and answer will be circulated in writing
  • Motions for Debate
    • LibDem motion about free school meals and the joy of a coalition government
    • Labour motion on the bedroom tax
    • Tory motion on asking the govt to reconsider decision to disband 2nd Btn Royal Regiment of Fusiliers, the successors to the Royal Warwickshire Regiment
Nothing controversial on there....

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Diary Date - Full Council AGM

Full Council
Tuesday 11 June 2013 - 4pm
Council Chamber
And you can now watch online here.

A foreshortened agenda and a late start today. Key items on the agenda will be:
  • Report of The Lord Mayor 2012/13
  • Election of The Lord Mayor 2013/14
  • Dates of meetings for coming municipal year
  • Annual constitutional review
  • Appointment of cabinet members
  • Appointment to council committees and other bodies
This is a meeting open to the public and we've certainly seen significant use of the online streaming - far more have watched online than have attended these meetings in a year.

We'll be welcoming Cllr Mike Leddy (Lab) as our new Lord Mayor for the coming year. He's a good guy and deserves the job - he will be an excellent first citizen of the city. 

Tuesday, April 09, 2013

Scrutiny Committee Report on Cycling

I didn't get called to speak, but here's the speech I would have given.

It has been a great introduction to the life of this council to have served as part of a group that has shown such cross-party agreement in setting a transformational direction for cycling and other forms of low-carbon transport in our city. In that mood, it seems appropriate today to borrow from the Thatcherite's Thatcherite, Norman Tebbit, as we encourage the people of Birmingham to get on their bikes. Indeed, only last weekend, one of my children went solo on his bike for the first time.

In particular, I welcome the recommendation that specific targets should be set - it was a criticism of the last strategy document that it was long on words, but short on measurable outcomes. This report has not made the same mistake and I welcome the executive commitment to take it through to delivery. We have a chance to build on the legacy of the Olympics, to seize the moment to take this city forward, but it takes commitment at the highest level amongst officers and executives to deliver on the ambitions.

This report is also about road safety - I would particularly encourage the spread of 20mph zones and limits across appropriate roads in the city. These will help make our neighbourhoods better places to live as well as delivering proven benefits in terms of reducing casualties and the severity of injuries. There is safety in numbers - the more people we can encourage to get on their bikes, the safer it becomes for them, as drivers get used to their presence, as Cllr Barnett pointed out.

A public outcry over road safety brought about a massive change in the Netherlands. They made the same mistakes that we did after the war, building cities and towns designed around car ownership. It was only at the start of the 1970s, following a rise in injuries to children, that they took a political decision to change direction and embarked on building the system that we see today. Make no mistake, this is a long term project that will take decades, but we need to make a start and this report is a good point.

As a committee, we have had sterling support from cycling evangelists like CTC and Sustrans, in the gallery today, as well as individual enthusiasts in the city, for which we are grateful, but the are not our target audience. We need to deliver, but not for those hundreds of indefatigable cyclists, who will resort to two wheels no matter how hard we, as a council have made it over the years. We need to deliver for those thousands, or tens of thousands, who will cycle if we make it easier and safer. We need to deliver on this for future generations.

Build it and they will come.

Location:Chamberlain Square,Birmingham,United Kingdom

Monday, April 08, 2013

Diary Date - Full Council - Tuesday 9 April 2013

Full Council
Tuesday 9 April 2013 - 2pm
Council Chamber, Council House
And you can now watch online here.

Key items on the agenda:
  • Question Time
    • Members of the Public to any Cabinet Member or District Committee Chair
    • Any Councillor to Committee Chair or Lead Member
    • Councillors other than Cabinet Members to Cabinet Member
    • Councillors other than Cabinet Members to Leader or Deputy Leader
  • Report of council business management committee
  • Reports of Overview & Scrutiny
    • Health of Birmingham's Third Sector
    • Changing Gear: Transforming Urban Movement Through Cycling & Walking in Birmingham
  • Motions for Debate
    • Tory motion supporting the alignment of government spending with the priorities of the local business community
    • LibDem motion about Pupil Premium
This is a meeting open to the public and we've certainly seen significant use of the online streaming - far more have watched online than have attended these meetings in a year. 

Tuesday, February 05, 2013

Diary Date - City Council Meeting - 5 February 2013

Full Council
Tuesday 5 February 2013 - 2pm
Council Chamber - streamed live too.

Key agenda items:
  • Question time
    • Public questions to any cabinet member or district committee chair
    • Questions from any councillor to a committee chair or lead member of a joint board
    • Questions from councillors other than cabinet members to a cabinet member
    • Questions from councillors other than cabinet members to the leader or deputy leader
  • Overview and Scrutiny Reports
    • Birmingham - Where the World Meets
    • Birmingham's Local Centres
  • Motions for debate
    • LibDem motion on community chest funding
    • Labour motion on youth unemployment

Tuesday, January 08, 2013

Diary Date - Full Council - 8 Jan 2013


Full Council
Tuesday 8 January 2013 - 2pm
Council Chamber - streamed live too.

Key agenda items:
  • Question time
    • Public questions to any cabinet member or district committee chair
    • Questions from any councillor to a committee chair or lead member of a joint board
    • Questions from councillors other than cabinet members to a cabinet member
    • Questions from councillors other than cabinet members to the leader or deputy leader
  • Localisation of Council Tax Support
  • Overview and Scrutiny Reports
    • Strengthening the Birmingham Family of Schools
    • Devolution - Making it Real
  • Motions for debate
    • Labour motion on local government settlement
    • Tory motion on biomass boiler emissions

Tuesday, December 04, 2012

Diary Date - Full Council

Full Council
Tuesday 4 December 2012 - 2pm
Council Chamber - streamed live too.

Key agenda items:

  • Question time
    • Public questions to any cabinet member or district committee chair
    • Questions from any councillor to a committee chair or lead member of a joint board
    • Questions from councillors other than cabinet members to a cabinet member
    • Questions from councillors other than cabinet members to the leader or deputy leader
  • Review of City Council's Constitution
  • Gambling Act 2005 - Statement of Licensing Principles
  • Reports of Overview & Scrutiny Committees
    • Closing the skills gap
    • Adults with autism and the criminal justice system
  • Motions for debate


Saturday, November 10, 2012

20s Plenty


This week, the Labour-run Birmingham City Council took a decision to develop a policy on creating 20mph zones in residential areas and around schools - building on the work being done by the Parliamentary Cycling Group and the Transport, Connectivity and Sustainability Overview & Scrutiny Committee. I spoke in favour of the Labour amendment to the motion and here's the original speech. 

Lord Mayor, I surprise myself today by speaking largely in support of a motion from the Liberal Democrats. Still, I suppose even a stopped clock is right twice a day – it is just a shame that they didn’t push this policy forward during the eight years that they were almost in power in Birmingham. This is actually a cross-party issue – 20mph zones were first introduced under a Conservative government no less, simplified by Labour in 1999 and have been expanded by councils of all political colours since.  This was discussed at a recent meeting of the Transport, Connectivity and Sustainability Overview and Scrutiny Committee and I would urge that the cabinet wait to take that final report into consideration.

The arguments in favour of 20mph zones in residential areas are clear. Slower speeds mean more time to spot hazards and more time to stop safely. At 20mph, the risk of a fatal injury is just 2.5%, compared to 20% at 30mph. And we know that these zones work – the 1996 Transport Research Laboratory report saw a reduction of 60% in injury accidents and child injury accidents were cut by two thirds. Hull introduced these zones widely in the mid 1990s and saw fatal and serious injuries fall by 90%, with pedestrian casualties halving and child pedestrian injuries dropping by three quarters. The BMJ conducted a review over twenty years and showed a 40% cut in casualties and a halving of serious or fatal injuries to children – outstripping the reductions shown on other roads. This isn’t just about the emotional cost to the victims and families. Bear in mind that fatal accidents have a financial cost too  - a fatal accident is assessed at £1.7 million and even a minor crash is costed at £21,000. Warrington saw an 800% return on the investment in 20mph zones based on casualties avoided.

Again and again, the evidence shows that 20mph zones and limits work to reduce injuries and costs.

There are other powerful arguments in their favour too.

Reducing the dominance of the car in our neighbourhoods makes them better places to live – quieter and more attractive to cyclists and pedestrians. In Bristol, they found in these zones, walking increased by almost a quarter and cycling by a fifth. Again, this brings broader, measurable health benefits – every pound spent on these zones brought a return of £24 for walking and £7 for cycling. Road danger actually increases the number of car journeys and by making our roads safer, more people are prepared to walk, cycle and use public transport. By further reducing car journeys like this, our roads become safer still – creating a virtuous spiral.  This evidence has seen Liverpool PCT invest £665,000 in establishing 20 mph limits and Bristol PCT was also supportive in that city.

Some claim that these zones increase fuel consumption and while it is true that car engines are not as efficient at 20mph as they are at 30mph, I don’t see much enthusiasm for increasing the speed limit to 60mph to achieve maximum efficiency. In fact, the German experience is that 20mph zones – or their equivalent – are more efficient because they cut out hard acceleration that uses fuel and hard braking that wastes that energy. Indeed, they lead to a 12% fuel saving, which means a saving in carbon and particulate emissions.
However, Lord Mayor, my experience in trying to change behaviour in the field of energy efficiency and transport has shown that we need to carry the people with us. People have to want to change. We cannot just impose these measures across the city, but we need to consult fully with other stakeholders and – most importantly – with our residents, perhaps even united across party divide. I feel confident that if we put the hard evidence before the people of Birmingham, they will support these measures that will improve their neighbourhoods and protect lives. I urge the Council to support the Labour amendment to this motion.
.  
Thank you, Lord Mayor. 


EDIT 14/11/12: Elsewhere on the net, somebody suggested out that I didn't understand the difference between 20mph zones and 20mph limits. I do - my phrasing may have been wrong (shoot me for trying to avoid being too technical - this isn't a legally binding document and zone is a convenient word). There is a clear difference. 20 mph zones have additional measures to calm traffic - speed humps and the like, while limits are just that. When the policy is finally formulated, both may be on offer, but funding is likely to preclude 20mph zones except in very rare cases. In any case, consultation will take place and residents' support will be vital to establishing the limit area/zone. 

This is also not "anti-car" as some would have it - I'm a car driver, as well as a pedestrian, a cyclist and a user of public transport. I probably use the car too much and I'm trying to use it less. People will always have to call on a mix of transport modes - we need to accept that, but that doesn't stop us trying to create a permissive environment that encourages them to use less carbon-intensive transport.

This isn't about being anti-car, but pro-people.

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

Diary Date - Full Council

Full Council
Tuesday 16 October 2012 2pm
Chamber, Council House and live streamed here (with a link to the full agenda).

Key items from the agenda:
  • Question time from the public & councillors
  • Review of City Council constitution 
  • Statement of Licensing Committee
  • New ways of working within Overview & Scrutiny
  • Motions for debate - one on Council Tax Benefit and one on proposals for tenant consultation



Thursday, June 14, 2012

Council Meeting - 12 June 2012

For the record, here's the text of my maiden speech (unchecked against delivery):

"I shall be brief, although I may take more than my usual 140 characters today.
It appears that the coalition that we endured for eight years has staggered on into opposition and despite two electoral thumpings, it just won’t die – it has become something of a zombie coalition, stumbling around searching for brains.

However, Lord Mayor, the serious issue is whether this Labour council should continue these policies and some figures were cited to advance that argument.

Certainly, the past few months have shown some improvement, but let us consider the record of the previous administration and their partners, the government.

Lord Mayor, the members opposite criticised the former Labour government for their handling of the economy through a global crisis.

I will remind you that when the Labour government left office in 2010, the national economy was growing and unemployment was falling again, as it was in Birmingham, where in May 2010, we had 47,950 people claiming JobSeekers Allowance.

Too many, Lord Mayor, far too many.

But now, we are being asked to celebrate the fact that thanks to two years of economic incompetence by the Tories and Liberal Democrats at national level and lack of response at local level, May 2012 saw 50,239 people claiming Job Seekers Allowance. And when we look at the detail, we find that Birmingham has the highest percentage of young people out of work of any of the core cities and that women have been disproportionately affected by the policies of this government.
 
The people of Birmingham know this, Lord Mayor, which is why they have rejected the coalition opposite in their thousands. They have voted for change and I am proud to be one of Labour’s 20 new councillors elected as a result this year.

We must make Birmingham the Enterprise Capital of this country. We must build upon the diversity of economic and cultural life in this city – our manufacturers, our retail, financial and professional services and we must work to encourage the new drivers in the economy, the life sciences, green technology and the digital creative industries.

Lord Mayor, it falls to Labour to work through the wreckage left behind by the previous failed administration and without a supportive government, to try to deliver the jobs and prosperity that the people of this City have a right to expect.
 
Lord Mayor, I urge the council to support the amendment to this motion."
Aside from me, three other new councillors made their maiden speeches - Lisa Trickett, Phil Davis and an excellent opening speech from Cllr Mariam Khan, who at the tender age of 21 skilfully put the long-serving Peter Douglas Osborne properly back in his box, after he condemned the Connexions service because after they closed, they had a misspelled sign on the front door. 

Sunday, June 10, 2012

Diary Date - Full Council - 2pm Tuesday 12 June

Off to the Council House again this Tuesday for the first full council meeting under the new administration.

The agenda has been published and aside from the usual matters, we can look forward to a revamped Question Time, including the first session where members of the public can put forward their own questions to the Leader and the Cabinet, providing they are submitted in writing either by email or post before noon on the 11 June. There are a few rules about the questions - they can't be vexatious or libellous, they must relate to matters that fall within the business of the City Council, they can't be repeated within six months and they mustn't relate to personal planning or licensing cases. If you fancy putting a question to the new leaders of Birmingham, you can send it by email to council.team@birmingham.gov.uk and you could be asking the questions on Tuesday. By the way - you have to be available at 2pm on Tuesday to ask your question as well!

I like this - it is demonstrating a real willingness to open the council up to public scrutiny. A number of other authorities do this around the country and I'm pleased that Labour are leading the way in Birmingham. Question time as a whole has been increased in length, to allow for questions to the executive members and to ensure that they are held to account properly and not relying on the stage managed annual report, which never offered an opportunity to seriously challenge the cabinet members.

We've also saved money by cutting out the meal break from the meeting and it should all be done and dusted in four hours rather than the usual six.

Other agenda items include a report on customer services, the future of the Civic function (relating to the functions of the Lord Mayor) and a couple of motions for debate.

You can find the details here.

Friday, February 10, 2012

Full Council - 7 Feb 2012

You can find a video record of this week's matinee performance here.

Of particular interest is the Liberal Democrat motion on the promised increase in tax thresholds. In the original form, the wording actually supported a tax increase by reducing these thresholds - something I wrote about here. Cllr Eustace's speech is particularly interesting, as it rambles over a range of issues and only occasionally makes passing contact with tax. While I agree with increasing the take home pay of some of the lowest paid in the economy, I hold that there are better and more efficient ways of doing it, as increasing the tax threshold actually benefits the wealthier more than it does the lower paid. It also has no effect on many pensioners, those working part-time or the very poorest, as they are already beneath the tax threshold and don't pay a penny. I wrote in greater depth on it on the other place.

During that, Cllr Reg Corns (Con) makes sound points - about job insecurity and that payday loan firms like Wonga.com are "the biggest enemy of the ordinary working man." These firms do charge terrifyingly high rates of interest - well over 1000% APR is common. Curiously, one of the investors in Wonga.com is not only a major donor to the Conservative Party (£500,000 in the past five years), but also came up with a plan to allow employers to sack workers without any fear of unfair dismissal action, despite a complete lack of evidence that this would make any difference to firms.